This post may contain affiliate links. This means that if you purchase something through this site I may earn a (dreadfully small but much appreciated) commission at no extra cost to you.
In the fight to save the Mendel Art Gallery in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada, here is my innovative idea.
Update: We lost the fight. Why did no one listen to me?
The great Mendel Controversy
The Mendel Art Gallery is a classic and much-loved example of Modernist architecture in Canada, so how can I leave my hometown of Saskatoon without mentioning the Great Mendel Controversy? The last time I was here it was the Great Mural Controversy, with a campaign to save my father’s – artist William Perehudoff’s – murals from the about-to-be-demolished former meatpacking plant. (This controversy ended when campaigners raised enough cash and interest to save the murals, now stored and awaiting a new home. Yay!)
The fate of the Mendel Art Gallery is uncertain
Crazily enough, the Mendel controversy is not making major headlines outside Saskatchewan, so if you live elsewhere, as most people do, let me fill you in.
Fred Mendel was a huge supporter of the arts in Saskatoon and the Mendel Gallery & Civic Conservatory is named for him. These days, a battle is raging over whether the Mendel should be renamed the Art Gallery of Saskatchewan and moved to the new Riverside Landing Project that the city is keen on promoting, or kept where it is, in the glorious yet problematic Modernist building just north of the 25th Street Bridge.
The hard truth about public funding
There is more public funding available, apparently, to build new buildings than to restore old ones. The new gallery would be attached to the new Persephone Theatre and everything would be shiny and new. There are many problems with the old building, like crap storage and crap office conditions for staff. Still, it’s historical, a legacy to the most important supporter of the arts the city has ever known. After escaping Germany during the war, Fred Mendel came to Saskatoon and set up Intercontinental Packers (ironically, the same meatpacking plant that just hosted the Great Mural Controversy).
Most importantly, at least to my young art-loving parents, he brought world-class art to the city. If they couldn’t afford to travel to the most artistic cities in the world, it was a way of bringing international art to Saskatoon. Suddenly, this little prairie town had Blue Rider paintings, Braques, Picabias, Renoirs, Vlaminks, Group of Seven, Emily Carr’s … you get the idea.
The solution
The Mendel Art Gallery is an eye-catching building in a spectacular location and it’s the most well-used public gallery I’ve ever seen. At the recent opening for artists Marie Lannoo and Ed Pien some 700 people showed up. It’s got a popular coffee shop, a plant-filled conservatory … and there’s free parking, too. The good thing is that even if the art is moved, the city has no plans to demolish the building like they did the old Capital Theatre (I’m still shocked at that! Shocked!) but it wouldn’t be filled with art.
The proponents, the PRO-CHANGE side, who will likely win, keep stressing that the new building will be FUNCTIONAL. What kind of sell job is that? It seems obvious to me that the only way to win the PRO- PRESERVE-OUR-HERITAGE side over is to make a building that’s even more sexy than the Mendel, one with more caché, glam and star appeal, and that’s why I have come up with a solution. You can thank me later, when Saskatoon is the centre of the world art map. My solution is … insert drumroll here … Guggenheim Saskatchewan!
Why we need a Guggenheim Saskatoon
Think about it. Where was Bilbao before it got a Guggenheim? Today, every self-respecting art snob in the world has made at least one pilgrimage to this northern Spanish city. Why shouldn’t they come here? Why should Bilbao get the Jennie Holzers in the lobby and the big Jeff Koons flower puppies? Saskatoon wants a flower puppy, too.
We could also get a big giant spider by Louise Bourgeois to spice up the riverside view. (Ottawa just got one, why shouldn’t we have one?)
The Benefits to Saskatoon tourism
Everyone would come here. We could boost tourism, fill city coffers and up our reputation as the art centre of the world. Think big, people! Think world domination! And keep the free parking, too!
Want to learn more?
Read about Mourning in Saskatchewan
Liz Youssef says
November 20, 2011 at 4:55 pmWe’ve heard about this on the west coast too, fear not! My father, John Climer, was director/curator of the Gallery for 16 years and the Mendel was a huge part of our lives. I wrote to the Star Phoenix in favour of renovating the Mendel but they didn’t print my letter. I’ve signed the petition. Here in Nanaimo we’re also dealing with a big bloated mayor so I know the frustration. Save the Mendel!
Dave Geary says
November 19, 2011 at 6:10 pmUpdate to previous comment posted here: There are about 2,200 signatures and almost that many wonderful, thoughtful, considered comments on http://www.savethemendel.org website to date (Nov. , 2011). They continue to be added almost daily. The cultural highjacking of the Mendel legacy can still be stopped. It’s not over ’til the fat lady sings… or in this case Saskatoon’s big bloated mayor, who engineered this whole shameful business in secret with a small cabal of others. It has been a case of venal small town politics at its worst. Most Saskatonians know that this cultural travesty is about real estate, not about art.
Jenny Morgan says
April 4, 2010 at 12:43 amHelp preserve the Mendel!
Please visit
http://www.savethemendel.org
for more info on the issue – and help by signing the petition!
(We have over 1600 signatures – please add yours!)
Rebecca Minton says
March 13, 2010 at 11:20 amIt occured to me and apparently has ocurred to others that a solution to the controversy might be to preserve an exhibition space in the existing Mendel Gallery for the Mendel collection and /or the collection of 19th and 20th C master works. This could be done regardless of what other municipal or provincial organization took over the building and indeed, might serve to bring in more people for that organization. Has this been considered I wonder?
Cathy Fowler says
March 9, 2010 at 3:09 pmI meant to say Flower Puppy !
Cathy Fowler says
March 9, 2010 at 3:08 pmI love the article and I think there should be a flower puppy in Saskatoon too.The Guggenheim is a great idea, something splashy , a real showpiece for Saskatoon!
amy says
February 18, 2010 at 2:07 amLove it! A fascinating story on a topic I knew nothing about. Save the Mendel Art Gallery!